Sunday, January 26, 2020
Differences Between Spice And CMMI Information Technology Essay
Differences Between Spice And CMMI Information Technology Essay Software quality is increasingly becoming a necessity with growing number of firms dependent on IT infrastructure and mission critical softwares for their business processes. The capability maturity model and SPICE have been the two most comprehensive models for software process development that have resulted in a robust system for improving development process (Marshall, Mitchell 2004). A lot of applications have been developed with the use of such models. However, in spite of a lot of differences between the two models, there has been little focus on the key differences between the two models. While the capability maturity model is the best known software process improvement, the ISO/IEC 15004 is a suite of standards that are expected to affect the continuous evolvement of Software CMM (Paulk 1999). In this essay, the basic aim is thus to lay down the primary and secondary differences between the two maturity models in SPICE and CMMI. Further, through diagrammatic representations, the paper tries to list out the key differences between the models. CMMI: The capability maturity model (more popularly known as CMM) had its origins from a book published in 1989 by Watts Humphrey in his book Managing the Software Process. The basic theme behind the capability maturity model integrated (CMMI) is process improvement (Glazer et al 2008). It must be understood that CMMI is a process model and not a process standard. CMMI consists of process oriented activities that can be used collectively to attain the process area and business goals of an organization. CMMI practices are also meant to encourage organizations to use other process models based on the organizations need and practices. Primary Attributes of CMMI: The capability maturity model has certain primary attributes associated with it. It has been observed by Hoggerl M and Sehorz (2006) that process area, goals and practices are the three key concepts of CMMI. As stated earlier, the CMMi is a list of pre-defined processes that are stated under CMMI. According to the authors (Hoggerl Serhorz), the CMMI consists of 25 specific process areas within the development processes. Primary attributes of CMMI according to these researchers are thus process management, project management and engineering and support (Hoggerl Sehorz 2006). There are five basic maturity levels defined in the CMMI model. These are detailed in the table below Software CMM Maturity Model Description 1. Initial Software processes characterized at this level are ad-hoc and occasionally chaotic. At this stage, very few processes are defined and the success of the processes depends on the individual efforts and heroics 2. Repeatable The process management processes are defined at this stage. They are basic in nature and are generally derived from earlier successes 3. Defined The software process for both the management and execution are defined and are well documented during this phase 4. Managed Detailed measures for the evaluation of the software processes 5. Optimizing Continuous improvement processes are carried out using quantitative feedback from the process and from piloting of innovative ideas Table 1. CMMI Maturity Stages Secondary Attributes of CMMI: Within the primary attribute of project management, the authors Hoggerl Sehorz (2006) suggest that there are some processes which are specific in nature. These are referred to as the secondary attributes of CMMI. Some of the common secondary attributes include planning, monitoring, supplier management and team management. Within process management too, there are certain secondary attributes. Organizational focus, definition, training and innovation are some of the common secondary attributes that can be placed under the process management criterion. The engineering section of the CMMI model has a lot of scope for improvements. Thus, the secondary attributes under this section are vital to the process improvement. Some of the secondary attributes under the engineering section include requirement management, integration, verification and validation (Hoggerl Sehorz 2006). Within the support section (primary attribute of CMMI), there are some secondary attributes too. These include con figuration management, quality assurance, decision analysis and organizational environment (Hoggerl Sehorz 2006). The entire set of attributes is better presented in the composite features diagram shown below. For understanding a composite feature diagram, it must be noted that the maturity of a software process is best understood in five different levels. Although these levels vary from organization to organization, they can still be generalized as initial, repeatable, defined, managed and optimized (M, Paulk. M, Konrad. S, Garcia.1995;M, Paulk.1999). During the initial level, the processes are not ordered. During this stage the processes are chaotic and mostly depend upon the individual efforts. As per its name, the repeatable processes repeats itself; the success of earlier processes. Therefore, Paulk et al (1999) states that the defined maturity levels in the whole process go through the standards policies to fulfill the process. A proper documented plan of action is one of the most important aspects in the completion of a defined maturity model. However, the managed maturity models are tested quantitatively for the processes and product quality (M, Paulk. M, Konrad. S, Garcia.1995; M, Paulk.1999). The optimized maturity models are concentrated on innovation and continuous improvements through feedback mechanisms. A look at the advantages and disadvantages of CMMI model would be in line with the above discussions. Advantages of CMMI: CMMI has a number of benefits. According to Konrad, Shrum and Chrisis (2003), the CMMI model provides a good coverage for the average product life cycle than any other process improvement products when they are used alone. Moreover, CMMI can be integrated with any of the other software improvement models and can be implemented to provide robust functionalities. Although the main focus of CMMI was on product and service engineering, it was also built to provide enterprise-wide process improvement (Chrissis, Konrad, and Shrum 2003). Disadvantages of CMMI: Even though CMMI provides with a lot of functionalities for robust functioning, it is still not easy to implement within organizations. CMMI is not a process; it is rather the characteristics defined that should be present within an ideal process. Thus, the problem with process improvement is not that of a missing standard but to implement the standard in the perspective of the organization (M, Niazi. D, Wilson, D, Zowghi.2003). Since CMMI does not provide the actual implementation steps, it is not advisable to use in certain scenarios. Diagram 1. CFD For CMMI With such a brief description of CMMI, the concepts about the model are made clear. The next section of the paper discusses about the SPICE or the ISO/IEC 15504 process maturity model. SPICE: (ISO/IEC 15504): The SPICE model also known as the ISO/IEC 15504 is an emerging international standard on software process assessment that defines the number of software engineering processes and scales them to measure their capability (Emam, Birk 1999). The basic difference between the CMMI and SPICE is that while CMMI is a model consisting of steps that might be required in an ideal software process; SPICE is a standard for software process implementation that needs to be followed. The emerging ISO/IEC 15504 international standard is an attempt made to harmonize the existing assessment of models that are in the common use. It is an European model that is based on the quantitative score of assessment associated with the performance of the organization or the project (Emam Birk 1999). A software process assessment (SPA) provides a quantitative score that reflects the organizations or projects implementation of the best practices as defined in the assessment model. Thus, the more number of best practi ces that are adopted the more higher the quantitative score is expected to be. This score obtained from the baseline current implementation provides a perfect framework for making process improvement decisions and also serves as a means of tracking improvement efforts. Attributes of SPICE: SPICE model is based on five different processes. These processes were created in different nationalities and became accepted internationally. The five processes are customer-supplier, engineering, supporting, management and organization. Each of these processes has a capability level on which it is marked quantitatively. These levels begin from 0 to 5 ranging from incomplete process (0) to an optimized process (5). These processes are further marked using what is called as process attributes. It is the base premise of the software process assessment that the resultant quantitative scores are the predictors of the performance of the project or the organization that is assessed. In all, there are nine attributes in SPICE. As with CMMI, the nine process attributes are linked with the five processes. The nine attributes are Process Performance Performance Management Work Product Management Process Definition Process Deployment Process Measurement Process Control Process Innovation Processà Optimization. Similar to CMMI, the ISO/IEC 15004 has five process areas. These are known as levels. Each key process area is described in terms of its key practices that contribute to satisfying its goals and are allocated to produce common features. These key activities describe the specific function of the infrastructure and activities that contribute to produce the most effective implementation and institutionalization of the key process area (Paulk 1999). These five process areas are described in the table below Level Focus Key Process areas 5 Optimizing Continuous improvement Prevention of bugs, defects Technology Change Management Process Change Management 4 Managed Product process quality Quantitative process management, Software quality management 3 Defined Engineering organizational support Organization process focus, Training programs, Process definitions, Integrated software management, Peer reviews 2 Repeatable Project management processes Requirements Management, Software project planning, Project Tracking Oversight Quality Assurance, Subcontract Management, Configuration Management 1 Initial Competent people and heroics Adapted from: Paulk 1999 Diagram 2. CFD for SPICE: Differences between SPICE CMMI: SPICE CMMI Primary Attributes: SPICE model is more focused on Process Improvement. Primary Attributes: CMMI model is more generalized as it considers the organization as a whole Secondary Attributes: Acquire, supply, develop, operate, evolve, and supporting software processes. Secondary Attributes: Optimizing, managing, defining, re-using the software processes. SPICE is a European model CMMI is an American model Not much difference between the lead-assessor and the other members of the team. Every member of the team is responsible. Heavily depending on the lead assessor, CMM was the earlier version of CMMI. OO-Spice is the latest version of Spice. CMMI integrated Spice in one of its process. ISO/IEC 15504 model. SPI (Software Process Improvement) model Thus, the differences between the process maturity models have been highlighted. With these differences, it becomes easier to identify whether or not a particular model (like CMMI) or a standard (like SPICE) might be usable in a given organizations scenario. Ideal Model CFD: The attributes of both the CMMI and SPICE can be integrated to provide an ideal model for software development. This model is represented in the below diagram. Diagram 3. IDEAL CFD Conclusions Recommendations: Both SPICE and CMMI are said to improve software process development. While the CMMI is a set of standard processes that need to be carried out for the ideal software development process, SPICE is a standard that needs to be followed for effective implementation. Although there are some differences and similarities between the two models, both can be used in a combination to provide excellent software development process. The ideal CFD lists out the key processes that are a combination of both SPICE and CMMI that can be used in the software development lifecycle. Both SPICE and CMMI can be used in different circumstances and/or can be combined according to the organizations needs. After evaluation the advantages and disadvantages of both the models/standards, it can be said that both SPICE and CMMI can be used in a combination to provide the most efficient models for software development. These models can comprise of stages which are a combination of both the recommended models. Thes e combinations would depend according to the requirements of the organizations. For organizations with little time requirement, CMMI would be beneficial since it first maps timings and then plans the modules of the software development phase. On the other hand, if the organization seeks to achieving and maintaining a high standard of implementation that can bring a competitive edge, then it might want to involve more processes out of SPICE or the ISO/IEC 15004 standard. Therefore, the use of a particular model is dependent entirely on the needs and requirement analysis of the organization.
Saturday, January 18, 2020
A Cinematographic Vampire’s Tale: Understanding the Symbolism Behind the Horror Icon
Cinema is the place where we as viewers engage in sharing a collective dream. Certainly, horror movies enrich us as viewers with the most dream-like of plots. This is because they open a portal into another world where we are allowed to engage with our nightmares. All over time various horror movies show us how normality is endangered by a monster, but the creature who has haunted the screen like no one is undoubtedly the Vampire. According to Ivan Phillips the figure of the Vampire has drifted and shifted through the pages of newspapers, travel journals, novels, poems, comics, and plays for 300 years, it has haunted cinema and television for almost a hundred, its shadow is creeping into the social, narrative and ludic networks of the digitalââ¬â¢. The image of the Vampire is constantly present in the virtual and literature culture of the twenty-first century. Although this being moved from its folkloristic origins in which he appeared in works of J. Sheridan Le Fanu, John Polidor i and Bram Stoker, the vampire still remains an iconic figure in Western Culture. This personage provides paradoxical fascination as it exists ââ¬Ëat the edges of what is deemed normal, acceptable and safe, the vampire embodies the foreign and the unfamiliarââ¬â¢. Although, the vampire is often seen as a bringer of death, there are numerous metaphorical meanings and readings of this being. Through Marxist discourse the vampire is portrayed as the monster of monopoly capitalism and the agent of foreign ownership. This idea of the ââ¬Ëbloodsucking capitalistââ¬â¢ is perceived in a negative way the Marxist community. In a xenophobic society this idea of the vampire embodies a general fear of the unfamiliar and may also constitute a racial difference. But the vampire not only represents the non-conformity it also alludes to an illicit desire. According to Jorg Waltje, this being is the embodiment of humanity's ââ¬Ëhopes and desires: beauty, strength, and immortalityââ¬â¢. Although these elements do not express fear in the same way as the vampire's link with death but in the same manner they express an external behaviour which puts at risk society's stability. The vampire hints to a sense of ââ¬Ëunsettlementââ¬â¢. Through his figure the viewer, in a quite troubled sense, comes face-to-face with the dramatization of humanity. As a creature, the vampire encompasses men's vulnerability and his inability to alter the laws of time. As Sarah Sceats states ââ¬ËVampires represent what we both fear and desire; they evoke a marginal world of darkness, secrecy, vulnerability, excess, and horror. Whatever they are, it is positively Otherââ¬â¢. This notion of ââ¬Ëexcess' was also tackled by Omar Calabrese in one of his chapters. According to Calabrese one could only escape from ââ¬Ëa closed systemââ¬â¢ through this notion of excess. The vampire represents this excess as he personifies ââ¬Ëthose aspects excluded or rejected by society, its existence in itself denotes excessââ¬â¢. In addition to this, Calabrese associates this vampiric excess to the exotic erotic which alludes to the scandal and breaks the boundaries of what is socially acceptable. In this sense the vampire's bite is linked with the erotic. Further to this ââ¬Ëexplicit erotic actââ¬â¢ we have an unavoidable act with death. It was Bram Stoker which explored this notion in his novel Dracula. In the scene, where Lucy dies we see an excessive use of the erotic; ââ¬ËShe seemed like a nightmare of Lucy as she lay there; the pointed teeth, the bloodstained, voluptuous mouth ââ¬â which it made one shudder to see ââ¬â the whole carnal and unspiritual appearance, seeming like a devilish mockery of Lucyââ¬â¢s sweet purityââ¬â¢. Through this, Bram Stolker illustrates us with an example of how death is linked to the erotic. The notion of ââ¬Ëexcess' is repetitively used and reused by Stolker. In fact, he describes Lucy as a ââ¬Ënightmare â⬠¦ hich it made one shudder to seeââ¬â¢ As viewers, as film enthusiasts or as junkies of the silver screen, we have grown accustomed to think that nothing happens outside of the frame. Yet this idea seems to crumble to the ground when it comes to Dreyer's, Vampyr. The latter haunts us with ââ¬Ëa distinctly innerving sense of not knowing where anyon e is, creating a feeling that anything culd be happening beyond the frame, in the ââ¬Ëblind space' in which the monsoter lurksââ¬â¢. Visually speaking, Vampyr resembles Jean Epstein's La Chute de la Maison de Usher and Bunuel's Un Chien Andalou. Dreyer's horror movie encapsulates ââ¬Ëclear moments of crossover between the two movementsââ¬â¢. Therefore Vampyr distinguished itself from other movies of the same genre because of the various artistic influences which left their imprint. Comparison can also be drawn between more contemporary movies which are not necessarily classified under an artistic movement but which are still relevant to vampire studies. Coppola's movie is separated by decades from its predecessors and is more straight forward in the narration of events. Visual metaphors are central to its filmic structure and the American directorââ¬â¢s interpretation is completely submerged in blood, but while this film is heavily conditioned by an erotic element, the scenes of blood in Vampyr are scarce. The ââ¬Ëspots of bloodââ¬â¢ carry psychoanalytic connotations. Barbara Creed states that the manifestation of horror is culturally and socially constructed through the ââ¬Ëimages of blood, vomit, pus. shit etcââ¬â¢. These images emphasize a split between the law of the father and the maternal influence. This division has to be viewed under a pre-Oedipal line of thought. In this stage there is a fierce attachment to the maternal figure. In Dreyer's vampire movie, blood is linked to the maternal entity because Chopin ââ¬Ëpunctuates the flesh and transgresses the sanctity of the bodyââ¬â¢. Another overwhelming point stated by Creed is that the female vampire does not limit herself to mutating her victims into creatures which are one with the night. Her victims are testimony of the vampire's ability to destabilize ââ¬Ëtraditional gender definitionsââ¬â¢. Although lesbian connotations are often attributed to this particular flick, there is no real intimacy between Leon and Chopin. The scene in which Chopin ââ¬Ëfeeds' upon her young prey, does not communicate a sense of desire. The village doctor who is at the service of Chopin, does not coincide with the medical man who represents a positive force in the traditional gothic horror narrative. In Coppola's Dracula, based on Bram Stocker's novel, Van Helsing is an educated individual and an adversary to the malevolent vampire. The doctor ââ¬Ësucks' the blood from the living thanks to the transfusion equipment just as Chopin uses fangs. The victim of the doctor's bloodsucking, artificial technique is Gray. He is the character who often looks at the actions taking place by standing behind doors or windows; ââ¬Ëhe is an outsider peering inââ¬â¢. In fact, Gray is removed from the narrative action even as he witnesses the first death. David Bordwell believed that Gray ââ¬Ëis a curious characterââ¬â¢ and he is more of a mediator than a provocateur of action. However, Gray still ââ¬Ëpossesses an active and enunciating gazeââ¬â¢. This male character's progress is often hindered by other characters, by the props and also by buildings. What is so overwhelming about Vampyr is the collision between reality and the supernatural. Everything seems to take place within a dream-like state and the movie is ââ¬Ëephemeral, polysemic and shifting, provoking opinion and polarising debateââ¬â¢. The movie afflicts the viewer with dissonance and discomfort, especially when our gaze meet Chopin's stare as Gray is sealed in the coffin. The latter is an artefact which shares an endless tradition with the general notion of vampirism. It is the space where these beings retreat and hide away from the daylight. The coffin is the body-fitting box where Dracula and Count Orlock patiently wait their time to rise while the vessel is sailing. This tomb or repository is ââ¬Ëthe most vampiric of all enclosureââ¬â¢. Gray finds himself trapped in a coffin and at this point in the movie's chronology, ââ¬Ëthe spectatorial gaze is doubly trapped, within the confines of a sealed coffin and the immovable dead bodyââ¬â¢. As the coffin containing Gray's corpse is being carried away, the procession passes next to Gray's unconscious body. In Vampyr, the element of the doppelganger has a heavy resonation. Vampyr is venerated amongst lovers of the genre even though movie makers throughout those years did not have the present technological resources. Old, B&W, silent movies may seem alien in form and content to younger generations, yet what some of these past flicks embody inextinguishable artistic and human values. We've already drawn remarks on Coppola's remake of Bram Stocker's narrative work into film. Long before the release of this movie, ââ¬Ëthe most haunting of any attempt to dramatize Bram Stocker's novelââ¬â¢ was Murnau's Nosferatu. There is a strong resemblance between Murnau's vampire and the one lurking in the book. What is it that viewers find so terrifying about Nosferatu? Is it the vampireââ¬â¢s appearance and inhuman gestures? Does he embody the general notion that ââ¬Å"we fear whatever we cannot explain or understand through rational thinkingâ⬠? As consumers, for there is no better way to call genuine movie enthusiasts, we ought to dig deeper and deeper into the sequence of images. Most of the time denotations come with connotations and it is up to us to fish out such hidden meanings. The imagery in Murnauââ¬â¢s movie suggests the concept of repression and ââ¬Ëthe arch is a visual leit motif in the filmââ¬â¢. Arches and similar structures try to stop the vampire from emerging. Count Orlock is therefore a repressed force who is also linked to Jonathan via these same arches. In a memorable scene in the movie, the Count emerges from under an arch and Jonathan from another as they meet for the first time. Jonathan is also linked to the menacing creature through the house which stands on the opposite side to his. Count Orlock purchases this house, thus becoming the young manââ¬â¢s reflection. Jonathan is a loving companion to Nina while Nosferatu becomes a ââ¬Ëdemonic alternative husbandââ¬â¢. Nosferatu contains numerous references to ââ¬Ëa number of traditional or cultural elementsââ¬â¢. Myths about Persephone and Orpheus also produce an echoing effect through this vampire movie. Nosferatu was not meant to float in its own air bubble, separated from all other influences and ideas. Murnau transfuses into the motion picture ââ¬Ëthe product of a synthesisââ¬â¢. This adaptation of Dracula, which donated to all lovers of the horrific this ââ¬Ëthin, repulsively baldââ¬â¢ being, dates back to ââ¬Ëthe heyday of expressionist fantasyââ¬â¢. What come into collision are the natural and the fantastic. These two distant realms are central to Nosferatu yet neither dominates the film. The viewer cannot but notice the obsession with filing space and the ââ¬Ëobrusive setsââ¬â¢. Like Tabu, Nosferatu is primarily set in natural surroundings and both of Murnauââ¬â¢s movies deal with a menace. The latter diffuses into an ordinary world and out of a fantastic, paranormal world. Nosferatu portrays an animal-like being (a mixture between a rat and a human skeleton) who is ââ¬Ëconstantly associated with nature throughout the filmââ¬â¢. Even Count Orlokââ¬â¢s movements does not coincide with those of a human being , in fact even his castle ââ¬Ëis like a natural continuation of the rockââ¬â¢ thus the true protagonist in Nosferatu is Nature which is closely linked with its natural settings. In Nosferatu, Murnau used a sort of trick photography also with expressionist angle shots. As Gilberto Perez Guillermo suggests these specific techniques are used to illustrate a remote, fragmented and bizarre environment. Nosferatu is generally seen from distance and this gives us the impression that the nocturnal creature is merging itself with the surrounding nature. Murnau succeeded into creating an iconic- power image through which he shows Nosferatu as ââ¬Ëseemingly immensely tallââ¬â¢. In particular the scene where the vampire is standing on the deck of the vessel which is no longer conducted by a human being. Murnau makes also the use of the negative image, this technique is ideal to express ââ¬Ëmystery, fantasy, and unrealityââ¬â¢. This negative image basically involves an X-ray photograph, in this film it was used when Jonathan was being carried into ââ¬Ëthe land of phantomsââ¬â¢ in Count Orlock's weird carriage. The three movies which have been discussed so far are all based on similar, if not identical, themes. In each case the relationship between the female character and the parasite represented by the vampire is at the heart of the movie's plot. Guillermo del Toro took on a different approach and directed a vampire movie which derailed from the norm set up by the previously discussed films. Narrative-wise, Cronos ignores the myth of the Count and focuses on a device that causes transformations to take place within the main character's physique. The Cronos looks like an insect which shares some sort of a mutual parasitic relationship with its victim. Apart from a different take on the blood-sucking creature's myth, Cronos proposes characters which are marked by an ââ¬Ëimplied absenceââ¬â¢. Del Toro's movie might ââ¬Ërepresent a nostalgic look at the pastââ¬â¢ in the sense that the long-gone years receive a corporeal dimension belonging to the present. The main character in this Mexican Gothic is a perfect illustration of this notion. Jesus Gris is the ââ¬Ëpurveyor of antiques and guardian of the new dawnââ¬â¢ the latter being Aurora. What distinguishes Jesus Gris with Dieter de la Guardia, the dying industrialist who is aware of the Cronos' true nature and powers are there past scars which must be dealt with in modern times. On the one hand the ââ¬Ëscarsââ¬â¢ of Jesus are related to family life while on the other Dieter de la Guardia is at the mercy of an ailing health. Above all else, the Cronos is a ââ¬Ëfascinating hybrid of science and natureââ¬â¢ and the golden case is said to hold an insect which lives off human blood. In return the creature rejuvenates its bearer and prolongs his life, killing off the threat posed by ââ¬Ëcorruptible, material fleshââ¬â¢. The device is needed by de la Guardia because it surpasses the technology of modern times. Only the Cronos can achieve what technology has failed in. There also lies a fine parallelism between de la Guardia and the angelââ¬â¢s statue. The manââ¬â¢s body is full of holes just like the archangelââ¬â¢s interior which is infested by cockroaches and if the statue reminds us of the divine, the deteriorating human body indicates an inevitable ending. Erotism is a stranger to the filmââ¬â¢s plot, yet del Toroââ¬â¢s work delves into universal dreams, such as eternal youth and the conflict between life and death. Jesus caries the device while de la Guardia holds the instructions; Jesus is the unsuspecting individual who comes across an artifact of mysterious powers and who ends owning itself to it. The Cronos dehumanizes him and his need for human blood becomes more prominent as the film unfolds. Just as the insect feeds upon the blood of the deviceââ¬â¢s holder, the latter ends up developing an appetite for human blood. Viewers have grown accustomed to having a female figure within vampire stories. Whether the woman is a prey, a victim or an object of desire, she has been instrumental to Draculaââ¬â¢s and Vampyrââ¬â¢s storyline. In Cronos, Aurora ââ¬Ëplays the role of the love interest for which the monster must make his sacrificeââ¬â¢. Transformation and shifting of form does not limit itself to Jesusââ¬â¢ metamorphosis, but it also manifests itself in the relationship between the vampire and the female figure. The erotism is replaced by an ââ¬Ëinnocent, filial loveââ¬â¢. Contrasting and comparing characters and plots allows us to point out what is present in one movie and absent in another. Some characters from different filmic works may share the same attributes or characteristics, while others may interpret the same role but in a totally different manner. The so-called ââ¬Å"assistantâ⬠, the faithful follower who is at the service of his master, is present in all four films discussed so far. However Angel, the nephew of de la Guardia, is not as submissive as Renfield and the village doctor. Angelââ¬â¢s mode of thinking is simply capitalistic. He yearns for his uncleââ¬â¢s wealth and represents the ââ¬Ëcynical angelââ¬â¢. In contemporary popular culture the power of the vampireââ¬â¢s bite did not vanish but in some manner it did change. We can see this notion through the creation of diverse pop culture vampires such as Angel and Spike in the series Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1997-2003). These modern vampires have been ââ¬Ëdesexualized and de-victimizedââ¬â¢ because they only obtain and drink blood from butchers. Now the vampire is made more human and this highlights the fact that contemporary vampires have a more mundane appearance. In the new millennium the vampire seemed to have changed from a creature of fear to a creature of ââ¬Ësympathy and emulationââ¬â¢. This is made more evident in online discourse about the vampire. As argued by Mary Williamson in her book Lure of the Vampire, in the virtual world the vampire is perceived as a ââ¬Ëforgivable outcastââ¬â¢ and thus we sympathize with him. In Facebook, a social network used by millions in the world the presence of this being is very strong. Through one particular application called Vampire application we see several imitations of the ââ¬Ëfolkloric tradition of the vampireââ¬â¢. This application is diffused from one user to another via a ââ¬Ëvirtual biteââ¬â¢. During this process a user is sent an invitation to enrol himself to such application, were the user gets to interact with other individuals who share their interest and curiosities about this subject. Users get to fight other vampires, fill their hunger or feed upon weaker vampires. Once cravings for this so called ââ¬Ëvirtual-violenceââ¬â¢ are stated by many, users can also send gestures such as hugs to their nearest companions. Feeding and fighting are the highlight of this application were vampires get points and money for doing so which than they can be exchanged for weapons or to improve their senses or powers . In this application placing someone in a suit will result in losing all their fights for two consecutive days, which is quite a deal breaker. This application also embraces violence amongst friends. Some of the many options this application boasts are the way one can attack another throughout the Facebook community. This application is filled with the erotic; this notion solidifies the ââ¬Ëtraditional elements of the transgressive vampireââ¬â¢. At each and every single level the vampire's abilities achieves a new rank and this creates a new type of vampire. As noticed by Mary Williamson in the virtual world this being is not perceived as an ââ¬Ëoutcastââ¬â¢ but rather a fundamental figure through which players communicate. In the online world the vampires have become a part of a different ritual, a social ritual by which relationships and friendships are maintained and expandedââ¬â¢. In this application, what used to frighten about this creature is eliminated and instead it is accepted. In fact, with the loss of penetration of the bite the vampire is ââ¬Ëde-sexualized and sanitizedââ¬â¢. According to C alabrese, the vampire represents only a slight alteration beyond what is socially accepted and thus it represents; the shifting of limits. ââ¬ËWhen confronted by an ââ¬Ëacceptableââ¬â¢ excess, the limit is simply moved (perhaps to a considerable distance) in order to absorb itââ¬â¢. When in the virtual world, elements like blood and the penetration of the bite are removed ââ¬Ëthe virtual vampire becomes the monster that is usââ¬â¢. In the twentieth century, sympathy for this being has grown bigger. In fact as stated by Williamson, this being has generated new implications and attitudes ââ¬Ëtowards the ââ¬Ëself ââ¬â¢ in the twentieth centuryââ¬â¢. There is a great desire to imitate the vampire not as a rebellious figure but rather to imitate a ââ¬Ëbohemian outsiderdom which locates the individual as the desirable outsider, the sympathetically alienatedââ¬â¢. In the virtual context perception of the self becomes ââ¬Ëfluid and flexibleââ¬â¢. As it is no longer linked with the body but it is highly linked with the fulfilment of desires. In this sense identity is constructed as one desires. The virtual identity can be understood through the Lancian psychoanalytic theory. ââ¬ËIn the online world the virtual identity is not reflected but is rather constructed; the subject is not created in the reflection but rather in the digital compositeââ¬â¢. This leads us to do a parallelism between the vampire and the virtual identity. According to Shannon Winnubst, the site represents the mirror reflection in which an individual forms and constructs his ideas about the self. On the other hand the vampire ââ¬Ëin lacking a mirror reflection, does not even register on the radar of identity-formation: he does not have the necessary condition for the possibility of becoming a subjectââ¬â¢. Also Rhonda Wilcox explored this theme using the imaginative Id and the Jungian shadow. According to Wilcox the online body represents the negative aspect of one's personality. In this manner the vampire is portrayed as the doppelganger of the victim before it was biten. Stoker's Lucy and Angel in Buffy are the perfect examples, Stokerââ¬â¢s Lucy from chaste to ripely erotic, or perhaps the souled and soulless incarnations of Angel in Buffy ââ¬â so too does the virtual body provide opportunity for the vampiric shadow to find form in cyberspace. As stated by Wilcox, the imaginative Id illustrates the unconscious which is repressed and which encourages the pre-vampiric identity to free itself. In this sense online where the personality is fluid the wishes of the Id can be fulfilled as there are no repercussions which constitute some sort of restriction in the corporeal world. When talking about horror movies there is a subtle difference between the onster and the human being. But as indicated in films by Dreyer, Murnau, Coppola and Guillermo del Toro a strong link exists between the two beings. The myth and the vampire have always been subjects of debates. Although there are number of similarities and differences between Vampyr and Nosferatu yet both films show us the vampire as being more than just a b lood sucking, nocturnal creature but it is also the representation of the darkest corners of the human psyche ââ¬ËFor this is one of the functions of our monsters: to help us constrict our own humanity, to provide guidelines against which we can define ourselvesââ¬â¢.
Friday, January 10, 2020
Ethical Lens Reflection
Ethical Lens Reflection US101 I use my reasoning skills (rationality) to determine what duties are as well as the universal rules that each person should follow (autonomy). By prioritizing the value of autonomy over equality my primary concern is prospecting individual rights. I believe this is always the best way to assure that everyone in the community is treated equally. Believing all person should follow the same set of universal rules so strongly that I resist making exceptions even when intuition suggests a more passionate result. I found this result to be very true of myself.My personal ethical lens may direct my academic behavior into the positives. If all is true as the ethical lens states then when I set my mind to a project, being the discussion questions or an assignment, I fulfill those tasks. Doing this will get everything in on time. My ethical lens influences my critical thinking knowing that I have to think things through, I ask questions when need be, and ensure all resources are verified as scholarly or peer reviewed. By following my ethics I will refrain from plagiarism making sure to cite or reference all sources as needed.Keeping my conscience clear in classes. One of my results was: Tools for analyzing problems, Reason. Using critical thinking skills is my preferred method for learning and problem-solving. It states that I tend to think through a problem carefully and dutifully research options to find the one that will allow myself to fulfill my duties. My focus on gathering and carefully analyzing all the available data so I can make fully informed decision. The classical value of Temperance shows that I value individual balance and restraint in the desire for pleasure as I seek to satisfy my duties.I also know who I am, so I can act with integrity in the exercise of all virtues. ââ¬Å"I am responsibleâ⬠is my key phrase. Because I value autonomy and rationality, I tend to assume that my own definitions of what a responsible perso n should do applies to everyone. I define an ethical person as one who fulfills their duties and does the right thing as an autonomous, fully responsible adult. For me, this is the fullest expression of fairness and justice. My gift of self-knowledge shows I am concerned with figuring out my duties, when I am at my best I know myself ââ¬â I know what I am doing and why.Because of this, when I say that I will do something or care for someone, I follow through. I am also able to live in the present, to determine what I need to do at any given moment to fulfill my responsibilities. I risk being autocratic or bossy. I require everyone to do things my way in order to measure up ethically. I tend to not consider other interpretations of facts or listen to other approaches once I have made up my mind. If I am not paying attention I can be tempted to excuse myself from following the rules. I insist that I really am being true to my core values, even when I am not.Iââ¬â¢ll convince my self that the rules were meant for other people or that the action I want to take really does meet my responsibilities, even though my responsible self tells me otherwise. My vice is that I can become overly judgmental and unrealistic. I must remember to think about the impact of a decision on the whole community. Sometimes individuals actually benefit by restraining autonomy for the good of the community. As I learn to consider other perspectives in my decision making process, I will live out the best of my ideals with compassion and care for others.Using the results from the aptitude competency exercise can help with my current career as well as in class. By focusing on customer needs and satisfaction; I can set high standards for quality and quantity; monitor and maintain quality and productivity, working in a systematic, methodical and orderly way, and consistently achieve project goals. By producing new ideas, approaches, or insights; I can create innovative products or designs , and produce a range of solutions to problems.
Thursday, January 2, 2020
An Analysis of the Arguably Unified Poem, Beowulf Essay...
An Analysis of the Arguably Unified Poem, Beowulf Beowulf as a less than unified work, more important for its historical and philological content than its literary merit, and critics after him regard Beowulf as a unified work of art. For example, of the critics who discuss the poem as a whole in An Anthology of Beowulf Criticism, most agree pace Tolkien that Beowulf is a unified poem, even if they argue so on different grounds. Burton Raffels introduction to his own translation offers a particularly exuberant example of post-Tolkien Beowulf criticism: [W]e are remarkably lucky to have [Beowulf]: not only is it unique, the sole survivor of what might have been a thriving epic tradition, but it is great poetry. Approached as anâ⬠¦show more contentâ⬠¦It is primarily for these reasons that critics prior to Tolkien argue against the unity of Beowulf. Though this paper agrees more with Tolkien and Raffel, it does not assume the self-evident unity of Beowulf; rather it will briefly review and assess the main issues relevant to the question of the poems unity, of which there are three: (1) Beowulfs structure, (2) the significance of its subject matter, and (3) its thematic unity. One possible caveat here is that modern ideas about artistic unity do not apply to Beowulf. H. L. Rogers makes this claim, for example. However, Aristotle presented sophisticated ideas about poetic unity long before Beowulf, and hence there is no reason to believe that Old English authors had primitive notions of artistic unity. Moreover, those who argue against the single authorship of Beowulf already apply modern standards of unity to support their case, as Rogers indeed does. Thus there should be no great objection to applying these standards in support of the opposing view. The prima facie evidence for the structural unity of the poem is strong. The narrative centers around three fight scenes that parallel one another and link together part one and part two. In each part, a monster plagues a helpless people, and Beowulf comes to the rescue. Throughout this basic narrative, there are themes of kingly wisdom and tribal loyalty, descriptions
Wednesday, December 25, 2019
Essay About Freedom - 839 Words
The struggle for freedom is big, people will always have reasons for not letting you have it. No matter what kind of freedom you want, you will always have to work and fight for other people and yourself to find it. Over the years there has been a lot of hate but also a lot hope, considering this there are a lot of controlling people who want power, but there is also a lot who are selfless and want that freedom from society and primitive thinking. These are qualities a lot of people have but, there is people who have persevered and never quit fighting for what they believe. In the collection of texts that weââ¬â¢ve read, freedom is obtained by never ceasing from fighting for what you want, no matter how many people donââ¬â¢t want you to have it.â⬠¦show more contentâ⬠¦These women didnââ¬â¢t care what the officials said or thought that they could or could not do, they were just tired of being treated that way. ââ¬Å"We confronted the regime as best we couldâ⬠(Sat rapi 84). This text represented the way Muslim woman did everything could and fight off and let the men know they were not going to give up. Even if they were small acts of rebellion, they were going to do their best to never give in to the way they were treating them and always fight for that freedom they so deeply needed. My last reason I have for making this claim is seeing the way Junior fought of all the stereotypes about Indians not having a future and never being able to leave the reservation. He went to Reardon no matter how much people hated him or judged for it because they all felt betrayed. They all didnââ¬â¢t believe he could do it just because they thought he didnââ¬â¢t belong there or maybe just because they didnââ¬â¢t think he was smart enough. ââ¬Å"Iââ¬â¢m never going to surrender to anyone, never, never, everâ⬠(Alexie 186). This passage shows the way he was not going to let anyone get in this way, even if the whole reservation hated him for leavi ng and finally getting freedom from all that negativity ,he just wanted to succeed. This meant he was always going to fight against those people and never give up even if everyone was telling him to fail. ââ¬Å"Iââ¬â¢m never going to quit living life this hard you know?â⬠(Alexie 186). With this quote heShow MoreRelatedEssay about Freedom917 Words à |à 4 PagesFreedom ââ¬Å"Freedom is never more than one generation from extinction.â⬠These are the words of Ronald Reagan, former President of the United States of America, speaking on the topic of freedom, a subject he frequently dealt with during his long presidency. Over the years, freedom in the U.S. has become an increasingly controversial topic, and the effectiveness of the government in affording these freedoms has been called into question. Through certain historical documents and events, the governmentââ¬â¢sRead MoreEssay about Freedom and Slavery772 Words à |à 4 PagesHistory 141 Freedom and Slavery The United States promotes that freedom is a right deserved by all humanity. Throughout the history of America the government has found ways to deprive selected people this right by race, gender, class and in other ways as well for its own benefit. This is a boundary of freedom. Boundaries of freedom outline who is able to enjoy their freedom and who isnââ¬â¢t. These people alter with time and as history unfolds. Slavery and the journey of their freedom was a big partRead MoreEssay about The History of Freedom 1654 Words à |à 7 PagesThroughout history freedom has had many different meanings and definitions; based on race, gender, and ethnicity. According to the dictionary freedom means the state of being free or at liberty rather than in confinement or under physical restraint (ââ¬Å"freedomâ⬠def. 1). Freedom may seem like something given to everyone however it was something workers had to fight for. Not everyone believed that workersââ¬â¢ rights needed to be c hanged, which led to a long battle between workers, employers and theRead MoreEssay about Freedom Riders1575 Words à |à 7 Pages Freedom Riders ââ¬Å"Freedom Ridersâ⬠were a group of people, both black and white, who were civil rights activists from the North who ââ¬Å"meant to demonstrate that segregated travel on interstate buses, even though banned by an I.C.C. Ruling, were still being enforced throughout much of the Southâ⬠(The South 16). The Riders attempted to prove this by having a dozen or so white and black Freedom Riders board buses in the North and travel through Southern cities. This was all ââ¬Å"a coldly calculated attemptRead MoreEssay About Freedom In School1181 Words à |à 5 Pagessomething about this.â⬠ââ¬Å"Destiny is right we canââ¬â¢t let this happen.â⬠Said Monse ââ¬Å"Lets sleepover at my house and we can talk about this there.â⬠Said Stephanie. Throughout the day I was wasnââ¬â¢t feeling like myself. I kept telling myself it was just a show. Then when I thought again my brain said it was an important show, I wanted to be surgeon when I was older and that show was all about that. Then itââ¬â¢s 7th period and I was ready to go to Stephanieââ¬â¢s house. I quickly called my mom to tell her about theRead MoreEssay about Freedom of the Flapper1618 Words à |à 7 Pagesfemale gender. The flapper embodied the idea of freedom from the usual duties of a young female in the 1920s. These women were no longer tied down with the expectation that they immediately become a wife and mother, as well as being conservative and modest. By diving into a look at the fashion, music, and lifestyle of the flapper during the 1920s it will become obvious that they were not only independent, liberated, and enjoying many more freedoms than they had previously throughout history, butRead MoreEssay about Voices of Freedom1053 Words à |à 5 PagesVoices of Freedom Critique This selection, Letter by a Female Indentured Servant, really gives you incite as to what life was like in the 1700s as an indentured servant. (Foner, 2011) The reader can really feel the pain she is going through while she was in America trying to pay her dues for passage to what they thought was the promise land. She wanted to ensure her father really knew what kind of horrible life she was living because of the details she included like she was whipped to theRead MoreEssay about Freedom of the Press5620 Words à |à 23 PagesFreedom of the Press Although a cherished right of the people, freedom of the press is different from other liberties of the people in that it is both individual and institutional. It applies not just to a single persons right to publish ideas, but also to the right of print and broadcast media to express political views and to cover and publish news. A free press is, therefore, one of the foundations of a democratic society, and as Walter Lippmann, the 20th-century American columnist, wroteRead MoreEssay about The Right of Reigious Freedom1219 Words à |à 5 PagesReligious freedom is arguably the oldest and deepest of rights embedded in the modern collection of liberties. Religion has been historically one of the most powerful forces in shaping the morals of humanity. According to the 1993 Project on Religion and Human rights; Religion is defined as: Encompassing a world view or set of beliefs, along with a value system and a way of life embodying and expressing these beliefs. They are not merely a matter of belief or doctrine, but actually constitute anRead MoreEssay about Roderick Chisholm on freedom of the will709 Words à |à 3 Pagesof whether we have complete freedom of the will or if our will caused by something other than our own choosing. There are three positions adopted by philosophers regarding this dispute: determinism, libertarianism, and compatibilism. Determinists believe that freedom of the will does not exist. Since actions are events that have some predetermined cause, no actions can be chosen and thus there is no will to choose. The compatibilist argues that you can have both freedom of the will and determinism
Monday, December 16, 2019
Parental Involvement Among Different Cultures ...
Parental Involvement among Different Cultures: Implications and Strategies for Families and Educators in the United States Sarah Cain St. Petersburg College Abstract It may come to no surprise to many families and educators in the United States that families actively participating in their childrenââ¬â¢s academic life (school, homework, extracurricular activities) is a key component in unlocking their children(s)ââ¬â¢ success in school. The struggle that educators face is the lack of understanding or lack of knowledge about how families in other cultures view parental involvement. It is important for educators to understand that not all families will have the same viewpoints on parental involvement, and educators themselves may have different opinions about parental involvement that are not unanimously shared among colleagues. This research paper aims to provide an in depth review of how parental involvement is viewed in different cultures present in the United States. This paper will provide discussion regarding how differing culture views affect education in the classroom. Furthermore, this paper should provide educators with strategies o n how to recognize, accept, and encourage family participation in all cultures present in the United States. This paper will focus on cultural views from European American Families, Hispanic/Latino Americans, and cultural views based on family dynamics (single parents, income-classes, same-sex parents). Keywords: Family Involvement, FamilyShow MoreRelatedFactors Influencing Parental Involvement, Motivation And Anxiety On Educational Success Of Adolescents2518 Words à |à 11 PagesInfluence of three factors - parental involvement, motivation and anxiety on educational success of adolescents Introduction Adolescents have different levels of educational achievements and socio-emotional nature. Educational researchers have proposed different theories to explain factors responsible for educational outcomes and socio-emotional nature of adolescents. In this essay, influence of three factors - parental involvement, motivation and anxiety on education outcomes of adolescents willRead MoreThe Early Childhood Education Of Literacy And Numeracy3635 Words à |à 15 Pagesone s family environment. Bronfenbrenner s (1979) ecological systems theory is the foundation of ecological and sociocultural guideline of literacy and numeracy education in early childhood settings. The theory are essentially a set of interconnected and yet isomorphic layers of systems that affect the development of the children from a social aspect, e.g. the microsystem describes the interaction between the carer and the child, mesosystem describes the interactions between the family and theRead MoreHomeschooling : Harmful Or Helpful?3610 Words à |à 15 Pagesare responsible in deciding where their children will be educated and this decision includes some enticing options. The topic of homeschooling has indisputably been up for debate in many eras, cultures, and locations. Ari Neuman and Oz Guterman (2016) state that the question relics, which educational strategy is more effective, which is better? Since every child benefits from being educated, the way in which their education is delivered is under subs tantial examination since every individual has theirRead MoreWhy The Option Of Homeschooling Surfaced3606 Words à |à 15 Pagesare responsible in deciding where their children will be educated and this decision includes some enticing options. The topic of homeschooling has indisputably been up for debate in many eras, cultures, and locations. Ari Neuman and Oz Guterman (2016) state that the question relics, which educational strategy is more effective, which is better? Since every child benefits from being educated, the way in which their education is delivered is under substantial examination since every individual has theirRead MoreTruancy in Our Schools: A Growing Problem2344 Words à |à 10 PagesThe success of our schools performing its primary functions of teaching, educating, and socializing the young is predicted on regular school attendance. Truancy is rated among the major problems facing schools today (Garry, 1996). Schools in some larger cities have reported absenteei sm rates as high as 50 percent per day (Allen-Meares, 2004). The issue of truancy compromises schools primary function and places our young people at risk. According to the Bilchik, truant students have the potentialRead MoreRisky Behavior : Risky Behaviors1639 Words à |à 7 Pages Risky Behaviors When asked the question regarding risky behaviors in African-American student peer groups, the Academic Dean had this to say: These teens or young adults have a different temperament thatââ¬â¢s responded to their good life with risky living. So, we must introduce equations into their lives. This means, we talk over big decisions ahead of them (or behind them) and define how one choice leads to a specific benefit, but another choice leads to a negative consequence. Then, we must makeRead MoreThe Relationship Between Socio-Economic Status and Academic Achievement 2604 Words à |à 11 Pagesliterature review is to examine the relation between studentsââ¬â¢ socioeconomic status and their academic achievement. To be more specific, the goals are to determine (a) what defines low income; (b) review identified student characteristics (e.g. parental involvement, ethnicity, and school location) that have an effect on student achievement; and (c) what current research is saying about the best practices are for addressing the needs of low income students within the school setting. This literature reviewRead More Contextual Factors8375 Words à |à 34 Pagesunexpressed needs for communication, and concern about being uncared by the busy health professionals, which affect their care for the childââ¬â¢s health outcomes. Conclusion. The ï ¬ ndings facilitate the development of family-centred care focuses on partnership of care between the nurse and family to enhance the Chinese familyââ¬â¢s active and participatory role. 1 Keywords: XXXX à © 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 1 J A N Journal Name 1 2 0 4 2 Manuscript No. B Dispatch: 22.10.12Read MoreThe Conceptual Framework For A Research Based Diet And Physical Activity Interventions5466 Words à |à 22 Pagesprevention programs, but their motivation to engage in such activities does not stem primarily from their desire to improve the health of their children and families. According to the CDC (2012), it has been identified an overarching desire among parents to feel better about themselves as parents that could in turn lead to pursuing improvements in their family?s nutrition and physical activity behaviors. According to Pocok (2010) parents want to lead by example, navigate their busy lives more efficiently,Read MoreSummary Of Funds Of Knowledge And Teaching Other Peoples Children3644 Words à |à 15 Pagesresearchers point out that in the past government policy for inequality was focused on how to make schools serve industry more efficiently. Connell, et al. (1986, p. 26) describe the difference in classes as stemming from people from different social strata having different attitudes, values, child-rearing methods, personality problems and so on. People from lower socio economic backgrounds do not achieve as highly because the homes they come from are unable to support them (Connell, et al., 1986)
Sunday, December 8, 2019
Annotated Bibliography in Australia - Free Sample & Solution
Question: How should Australia regulate voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide? Answer: White, B. and Willmott, L. (2012). How should Australia regulate voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide?. Journal of Law and Medicine, 20(2). The most significant objective of this paper on voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide is to give a fundamental base on which the initial discussion on this issue can be raised. The authors through this article attempts to give a wide perspective on this issue of euthanasia and assisted suicide and also raise some very evident questions relating to the law that needs to be modified in order to incorporate these issues of euthanasia (White and Willmott, 2012). The article does not aim to persuade the people or the government to make proper laws for or against this element. Instead the article tends to address all the issues relating to euthanasia more or less in a neutral manner and also tends to raise factors which are relevant to both sides of the argument. The article explores the legal policies of the country considering the decisions that can be made to end the lives. It elaborately describes the different laws with regard to the decision to withdraw or stop any life sustaining treatment which can result in the death of a person and how these decisions are considered under the Australian legal system. The article states how the Australian legal system considers it to be lawful to stop the life sustaining treatment of any person or to stop giving treatment to the people when such treatment is of no use to the person. The laws as the article states further provides that the proper painkilling if taken shall not give rise to any criminal responsibility. Contrastingly, it should be noted that both voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide is considered unlawful in the country and dealing with such cases would lead to a prosecution in the court of law. The legal implications can lead to the convictions under the laws for murder, suicide, abetment for suicide etc (White and Willmott, 2012). However, it should also be noted that even though there are many laws relating to these there are many such cases of voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide that is occurring in the country. The article states that there are a number of evidences which prove that even though there are laws restricting euthanasia many cases of assisted suicide and voluntary euthanasia has been occurring in the country. The article further goes on to describe the role of the political parties in their efforts to modify the existing law in this regard. In the Northern territory assisted suicide and voluntary euthanasia had been made lawful for a certain period of time. Otherwise, throughout the country there have not been many changes with regard to the laws in euthanasia and assisted suicide. The article proceeds to discuss the various laws that are prevalent throughout the different jurisdictions in the country. It states that there are quite a few jurisdictions where the laws relating to euthanasia is lenient and it is allowed in some countries. There are a number of countries as well where euthanasia is permitted. For instance, in the country of (Dupuis, 2003), euthanasia is permitted but there also exist laws and statutes that regulate the rules and regulations on voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide. Even in the European countries of Belgium and Luxembourg and in the states of United States of America there exist proper statues and laws with regard to euthanasia (White and Willmott, 2012). The legislative structures in these countries give detailed study on the incorporation of the review and processes that entitle the collection of the different data on how the law is to be implemented. Due to the following of this process there exists a considerable amount of evidence that shows the methods on which the operations with regard to the law can be assessed. In the country of Switzerland, the assisted suicide is permitted when such a thing is done without any motive (Bury, 2003). This effort of the country has been cons idered to be euthanasia tourism in the country. This particular thing has also been mentioned in the article. The article further analyses all the possible arguments both for and against of euthanasia and assisted suicide. The arguments for euthanasia state that the there needs to be proper reforms in law and these include public opinion that roots for reforms in this area, autonomy to a certain extent. It also needs to be stated that the present laws prevailing in this area is extremely discriminatory and illogical (White and Willmott, 2012). Some of the primary arguments against making voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide are that with regard to the sanctity of life it would be unethical to voluntarily make a person die (Cordner and Ettershank, 1996). These arguments primarily are concerned with how effective the standards and whether euthanasia would be ethical to be used on minors or adults when such an act is not voluntary. The article further attempts to proceed with the other issues in the arguments of euthanasia which are generally not been considered by the scholars during their research in this issue. The ethical issues relating to this concept has also been considered by the authors in this article. The ethical issues are connected to both for and against the arguments of euthanasia and tried to consider the broad aspect in this issue (Parker, 1994). The article than proceed to make a structure on how the legal system in Australia should move forward to regulate the issues of assisted suicide and voluntary euthanasia. The authors critically analyses on the issue as to whether these would be considered as criminal acts. In case assisted suicide and voluntary euthanasia is considered to be a criminal responsibility (Ragg, 1992), it needs to be enquired whether modifications in the law is required in order to make the laws even more strict or the laws should be kept unchanged. In case research states that modification in the law is required then it needs to be mentioned as to how the criminal law should be formulated in order to punish people connected with voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide (Doyal and Doyal, 2001) (Varelius, 2013). Some of the options that may be available for criminal punishments are reforms, creation of the offences that are context-specific, developing guidelines on the methods in which the criminal justice system should be dealing with the issues of euthanasia. The article after giving an unbiased view on the legal system on euthanasia later moves on to discuss how this concept when not criminalized would bring forward questions as to how these acts can be regulated and allowed. The article further suggests some reforms which can be applied in the legal system in this regard. These reforms include making such decisions which are voluntary as well as capable and the ability of the person to make use of the legal regime set by the government. The legal structure should set out procedures as to how the decisions need to be made with regard to the person who is suffering from any terminal illness or pain or sufferings (White and Willmott, 2012). The authors in this article state that if voluntary euthanasia or assisted suicide is decriminalized the validity of the laws on euthanasia and assisted suicide would be questioned and hence an appropriate statutory practice needs to be recognized in order to put regulations on this practice. The article primarily deals with the regulation of voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide that arises with the social and medical context (Randall and Downie, 2010). The present generation as stated in the article would not agree to be subject to the paternal medical practices present and would rather insist that they have more control over the process in which they die. The article highlights the debate which exists in contemporary time regarding the advancements made in medicine in this field. As a result of these advancements life sustaining medical treatment would be able to make patients live longer than usual (White and Willmott, 2012). Hence under such circumstances considering this process of euthanasia also becomes significant. As concluding remarks it can be stated that the article is extremely well written and it covers all the essential aspects with regard to voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide. It critically examines the contemporary laws in the country of Australia relating to this issue (Ulsenheimer, 2000). The article further compares the laws of the country with that of the other countries such as Netherlands, Belgium and some of the states of United States of America. The article further helps readers to look at both the aspects of the arguments for and against euthanasia and assisted suicide and also analyses the issue based on the ethical grounds. Hence the article very elaborately discusses this issue on voluntary euthanasia along with the existing ethical debates. This study would be appropriate for readers intending to gain knowledge on the existing laws on euthanasia in the country and also receive a view on the different aspects of euthanasia. References Bury, B. (2003). Assisted suicide and euthanasia in Switzerland: Doctors should keep out of it.BMJ, 327(7405), pp.52-52. Cordner, S. and Ettershank, K. (1996). Australia says no to euthanasia.The Lancet, 348(9043), p.1730. Doyal, L. and Doyal, L. (2001). Why active euthanasia and physician assisted suicide should be legalised.BMJ, 323(7321), pp.1079-1080. Dupuis, H. (2003). Euthanasia in the Netherlands: 25 years of experience.Legal Medicine, 5, pp.S60-S64. Parker, M. (1994). Active voluntary euthanasia and physician assisted suicide: A morally irrelevant distinction.Monash Bioethics Review, 13(4), pp.34-41. Ragg, M. (1992). Australia: For or against euthanasia?.The Lancet, 339(8796), pp.800-801. Randall, F. and Downie, R. (2010). Assisted suicide and voluntary euthanasia: role contradictions for physicians.Clinical Medicine, 10(4), pp.323-325. Ulsenheimer, K. (2000). Legal Aspects of Active and Passive Euthanasia.Der Gynkologe, 33(10), pp.734-739. Varelius, J. (2013). Voluntary Euthanasia, Physician-Assisted Suicide, and the Right to do Wrong.HEC Forum, 25(3), pp.229-243. White, B. and Willmott, L. (2012). How should Australia regulate voluntary euthanasia and assisted suicide?.Journal of Law and Medicine, 20(2).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)